Scotland’s Euro 2024 dream is hanging by a thread after their devastating 5-1 defeat against Germany. As they prepare to face Switzerland, there are several conundrums that need to be addressed in order to salvage their chances.
The first conundrum revolves around the goalkeeper. Angus Gunn, who received criticism for his performance against Germany, is still seen as Scotland’s number one. Leanne Crichton believes that changing the goalkeeper after just one game would be unfair, and that Gunn deserves the opportunity to redeem himself. Neil McCann echoes this sentiment, stating that Gunn has earned the right to be the first-choice goalkeeper. However, Steven Thompson acknowledges that it wasn’t Gunn’s best game and suggests that there are good alternatives in Zander Clark and Liam Kelly.
The second conundrum lies in Scotland’s defense. The back line was repeatedly exposed by Germany, and with Ryan Porteous suspended, there is a need for adjustments. Crichton believes that manager Steve Clarke will stick with his loyal and consistent team selection. Grant Hanley will replace Porteous in the center, and there could potentially be a change at right-wing-back. Crichton suggests James Forrest as a possible option. McCann proposes a more aggressive approach, moving Jack Hendry to the right and Kieran Tierney to the left of the back three. He also suggests using Forrest as a right wing-back to exploit Switzerland’s weaknesses. Thompson, on the other hand, would change the formation to a four and select McCrorie, Hendry, Tierney, and Andy Robertson.
The third conundrum centers around Billy Gilmour and the midfield. Gilmour’s absence was felt in the match against Germany, and there have been calls for him to start against Switzerland. Crichton believes that Gilmour will come in and Ryan Christie will be dropped. McCann initially left Gilmour out of his selection for Germany, but now recognizes his importance for Scotland’s composure and bravery on the ball. Thompson also includes Gilmour in his preferred lineup, playing alongside Callum McGregor in a deeper position.
The final conundrum is the striker position. Scotland failed to register a shot on target against Germany, with Che Adams struggling due to a lack of service. Crichton believes that Adams will be backed, but she personally would love to see Lawrence Shankland start with John McGinn and Scott McTominay supporting. McCann favors Shankland, praising his goal return and overall play. Thompson also leans towards Shankland due to his impressive goals-to-games ratio.
In order to keep their Euro 2024 dream alive, Scotland must address these conundrums and make the necessary adjustments. The goalkeeper situation, defense, midfield, and striker position all require careful consideration. With their fate hanging in the balance, Scotland can ill-afford any mistakes as they face Switzerland in a crucial match.