The Pros and Cons of Having Two Top Goalkeepers in One Squad

Having two top goalkeepers in one squad can be both a blessing and a challenge for any manager. Arsenal’s Mikel Arteta is currently facing this dilemma as he tries to keep both David Raya and Aaron Ramsdale happy. In this article, we will explore the advantages and disadvantages of having two top goalkeepers in a team.

The Advantages

1. Competition and Improved Performance: Having two top goalkeepers creates healthy competition within the squad. Each goalkeeper will strive to outperform the other, pushing themselves to their limits and constantly improving their skills. This competition can lead to better performances on the pitch.

2. Injury and Suspension Cover: Injuries and suspensions are common in football, and having two top goalkeepers ensures that the team has a reliable replacement ready to step in when needed. This provides a sense of security and reduces the risk of a goalkeeper crisis.

3. Tactical Flexibility: With two top goalkeepers, managers have the flexibility to adapt their tactics based on the opposition. They can choose a goalkeeper who excels in certain aspects of the game, such as shot-stopping or distribution, depending on the team they are facing.

The Disadvantages

1. Lack of Game Time: One of the main challenges of having two top goalkeepers is managing their game time. Both goalkeepers will want to play regularly, and if one is consistently benched, it can lead to frustration and a potential desire to leave the club. Balancing their playing time can be a delicate task for the manager.

2. Squad Harmony: Having two top goalkeepers can create tension and disrupt the harmony within the squad. If one goalkeeper feels that they are not being treated fairly or given equal opportunities, it can create a divide among the players. Maintaining a positive team atmosphere becomes crucial in such situations.

3. Financial Considerations: Having two top goalkeepers can be costly for a club. They may have to invest significant funds in acquiring and maintaining these players. This financial burden can limit the resources available for strengthening other areas of the team.

Overall, having two top goalkeepers in one squad has its advantages and disadvantages. It is up to the manager to effectively manage their playing time and maintain squad harmony to make the most out of this situation. With careful planning and communication, having two top goalkeepers can be a valuable asset for any team.

Listen to the MOTD Top 10: Goalkeeping Blunders, only on BBC Sounds, or watch the boxset on BBC iPlayer