Oilers Amateur Scouts Excel Beyond First Round: Lowetide Report
The Edmonton Oilers’ amateur scouts have often faced criticism for their draft selections, particularly in the first round. However, a closer look at their track record reveals that they have actually performed quite well in recent years.
First Round Successes
While the Oilers have made some questionable choices in the first round, they have also made some excellent picks. Evan Bouchard, a defenseman selected in 2018, has become an impact player in the NHL and is even receiving consideration for the Norris Trophy. Kailer Yamamoto, the smallest first-round pick in team history, has proven to be a productive player and a regular in the NHL. Dylan Holloway, known for his athleticism, is showing promise with his recent goal-scoring streak in the AHL. Xavier Bourgault, however, has struggled to adjust to the professional level and is currently a concern for the team.
Second Round Steals
Fans often criticize the Oilers for their lack of success outside of the first round. However, their second-round picks have yielded some impressive results. Ryan McLeod, a center known for his speed and play-reading ability, has become an important player for the organization. Olivier Rodrigue, a developing goaltender, has shown promise in the AHL and may have a chance at becoming a backup or even a starter in the near future. Raphael Lavoie, a talented scorer, faces tough competition on the wings but has the potential to make it to the NHL. Tyler Benson, unfortunately, has seen his career hindered by injuries and has struggled to make an impact. Beau Akey, a puck-moving defenseman, has shown potential but needs to prove his health and display his talent.
Later Round Gems
The Oilers have also found success in later rounds of the draft. Stuart Skinner, a goaltender the team traded up to select, has solidified the goaltending position and has become a key player for the organization. Vincent Desharnais and Mike Kesselring, chosen deep in the draft, have both developed into legitimate NHL players.
Overall Success
Despite the criticism they often face, the Oilers’ amateur scouts have performed well in recent years. In the five years from 2014 to 2018, they drafted seven players outside of the first round who have played over 100 games in the NHL. When including their first-round picks, the scouts found a total of 12 players in those five years. Considering the limited number of picks they have had in the last decade, their record at the draft table is commendable.
Conclusion
While the Edmonton Oilers’ amateur scouts have received their fair share of criticism, a closer analysis shows that they have actually performed quite well in recent years. They have made successful picks in both the first and second rounds, as well as finding gems in later rounds. Their track record at the draft table has earned more respect than they have been given, and if players like Holloway continue to develop, their success will only improve.