David de Gea is leaving Manchester United after 12 years of service, and the Spanish goalkeeper departs with a personal high, having just won his second Premier League Golden Glove for the most clean sheets in a season. But how does he compare with some of the other great Premier League keepers? BBC Sport takes a look.
Trophies
De Gea won one Premier League title, one FA Cup, two EFL Cups and the Europa League during his time at Manchester United. While this is an impressive haul, it is overshadowed by the likes of Peter Schmeichel and Ederson who have a record five Premier League winners’ medals each.
Clean Sheets
Only three goalkeepers have ever kept more Premier League clean sheets than De Gea – with former Chelsea and Arsenal man Petr Cech top by far with 202. David James is second on 169, and Mark Schwarzer is third on 151. De Gea’s 17 clean sheets last season took him above David Seaman, Nigel Martyn, Pepe Reina, Brad Friedel, Tim Howard and Edwin van der Sar. For clean sheets at one club, De Gea is second to Cech and his 162 for Chelsea.
Saves
De Gea is ranked third for Premier League saves since Opta started recording that data in 2003-04. Ben Foster tops the way with 1,248 saves – aided by longevity and playing for some of the league’s weaker teams like Watford, Birmingham and West Brom. Finn Jussi Jaaskelainen is next on 1,223, and De Gea follows on 1,157 (2.8 saves a game). Since De Gea’s United debut, his 72% save ratio in the Premier League is only below Cech, Liverpool’s Alisson and Newcastle’s ex-Burnley keeper Nick Pope (of players to make 100 or more appearances).
Longevity
De Gea made 415 Premier League appearances, with only six goalkeepers featuring more times in the division. That is particularly impressive when you consider De Gea played 57 times in La Liga for Atletico Madrid before joining United and, at the age of 32, could have another 200 league appearances ahead of him. Former England keeper David James tops the list on 572 games – and also the list of goals conceded (665) as a result. Mark Schwarzer follows next on 514 games, and also for goals conceded (653). Republic of Ireland icon Shay Given played 451 times for Blackburn, Newcastle, Manchester City, Aston Villa and Stoke, conceding 607 goals. Brad Friedel, who played for Liverpool, Blackburn, Villa and Tottenham, is next on 450 games (567 goals). Cech played 443 times – only letting in 366 goals – with Jaaskelainen next on 436 games (613 goals). De Gea conceded 446 goals in his 415 English top-flight games.
Individual Trophies
De Gea won two Premier League Golden Gloves, in 2017-18 and the season just gone. He is one of only six keepers to win it more than once. Leading the way on four are Cech and Celtic’s Joe Hart, who played for Manchester City, Birmingham, West Ham and Burnley. Ederson and Pepe Reina, who played for Liverpool and Aston Villa, have three each, and Alisson has two. De Gea has a joint record four Manchester United player of the season awards (2014, 2015, 2016 and 2018), level with Cristiano Ronaldo. Nobody else has more than two.
Anything Else?
Since De Gea’s Manchester United debut, he conceded 426 – but the expected goals from those shots totalled 467, meaning he effectively denied an extra 41 goals. Only Tottenham’s Hugo Lloris denied more in that time, 48 (380 goals from 428 expected goals). In that time, De Gea ranks sixth for errors leading to goals with 17. Asmir Begovic is top with 25, followed by Lloris’ 24.
How Does He Compare With Other United Keepers?
United’s top three goalkeepers in the Premier League era are widely considered to be Denmark’s Schmeichel and the Netherlands’ Van der Sar – who each won a Champions League for the club – plus De Gea. Schmeichel won five Premier League titles to Van der Sar’s four and De Gea’s one. De Gea, with 147 clean sheets, beat the pair for clean sheets though. Van der Sar kept 132 and Schmeichel had 128 – both including for other clubs. With De Gea and defender Phil Jones leaving the club this summer, no players left at United have played under legendary manager Ferguson or won the title with the club.
Conclusion
David de Gea leaves Manchester United as one of the greatest goalkeepers in Premier League history. He won one Premier League title, one FA Cup, two EFL Cups and the Europa League during his time at Old Trafford. He is third for Premier League saves since Opta started recording that data in 2003-04 and made 415 Premier League appearances – with only six goalkeepers featuring more times in the division. He won two Premier League Golden Gloves and a joint record four Manchester United player of the season awards. Since his debut for the Red Devils he conceded 426 goals but the expected goals from those shots totalled 467 – meaning he effectively denied an extra 41 goals. He leaves as one of United’s top three goalkeepers in the Premier League era alongside Peter Schmeichel and Edwin van der Sar.