Edmonton Oilers Defenseman Philip Broberg Demoted Amid Trade Speculation

Philip Broberg, a defenseman for the Edmonton Oilers, has been demoted to the AHL Bakersfield Condors this week. This move has sparked trade speculation and raised questions about how the story became public.

While this demotion has caused quite a stir in Edmonton, it is unlikely to be as significant as some of the most famous demotions in team history. Broberg is expected to resume his NHL career soon, possibly with the Oilers, as he is currently ranked as the team’s seventh-best defenseman.

Over the past 44 years, the Edmonton Oilers have had several memorable recalls and demotions. Here are some of the most famous demotions in team history:

1. Mark Messier Sent Down to the Houston Apollos, October 1979

In his rookie season, Mark Messier struggled to score and was sent down to the minors by coach Glen Sather. However, Messier’s demotion was not solely based on his on-ice performance. The young forward also faced personal challenges, including missing practices and flights. Messier returned to the team two weeks later and went on to have a Hall of Fame career.

2. Grant Fuhr Optioned to the Moncton Alpines, January 1983

After a strong rookie season, Grant Fuhr had a difficult second season and faced criticism from fans. Following a game against the Detroit Red Wings, where Fuhr allowed four goals, he expressed his frustration with the fan reaction in a postgame interview. As a result, Fuhr was sent to the minors. Despite this setback, Fuhr went on to have a successful career with the Oilers, contributing to their Stanley Cup victories.

3. Sheldon Souray Loaned to the Hershey Bears, October 2010

During the “decade of darkness,” Sheldon Souray was a standout player for the Oilers. However, injuries and poor communication with management led to his demotion. Souray’s frustrations were publicly expressed in an interview with reporter Mark Spector. He eventually moved on to play for other teams, while the Oilers continued to struggle.

4. Jack Campbell Sent to the Bakersfield Condors, November 2023

Jack Campbell’s recent demotion is still unfolding, making it difficult to assess its historical significance. However, it is seen as part of a series of aggressive moves by new CEO Jeff Jackson, which may differ from the patient approach of general manager Ken Holland. Campbell is expected to be recalled soon and has the opportunity to prove himself in the NHL.

The Importance of Demotions

Demotions serve as a way for NHL teams to develop talent and allow struggling or injured players to regain their form. For Broberg, his demotion provides an opportunity to gain more playing time and experience in different roles. The Edmonton Oilers are in need of value contracts and players with potential for future success.

It is crucial for the franchise and Broberg to find a way to make this demotion work. Failure to do so could result in the Oilers receiving less than full value for their players, continuing a frustrating trend of transactions.

(Photo of Jack Campbell: Perry Nelson / USA Today)