Aston Villa’s ambitions to upgrade their squad and compete in the Champions League are hindered by the Profit and Sustainability Rules (PSR). One area they are considering improving is the left-back position, which is crucial in Unai Emery’s asymmetrical build-up system. Currently, Lucas Digne and Alex Moreno are competing for the same spot. Both players offer similar output and are practically the same age. However, due to financial constraints and Moreno’s recurring hamstring issues, Villa may have to let one of them go.
Digne and Moreno are both adept at receiving progressive passes, which aligns with Emery’s desire for full-backs to stay high and wide like wingers. Defensively, they have similar activity levels, as neither player is particularly aggressive or front-footed. Their trajectories at Villa have crossed, with Digne being favored last season after Moreno’s struggles with injuries. Villa has considered signing Sevilla’s Marcos Acuna as a replacement for Digne, but the Frenchman ultimately stayed.
Digne has been a reliable performer for Villa, offering improved attacking threat and defensive solidity. He excels in aerial duels, winning significantly more than Moreno. The 30-year-old understands the importance of proving his worth in pre-season and is determined to retain his spot. Digne’s pedigree, having played for Barcelona and France, has played a part in his revival.
Both Digne and Moreno are highly regarded by their teammates and want to stay at Villa. They have different personalities, with Moreno being more vocal and expressive, while Digne is more focused and dedicated off the field. Digne’s mindset has helped him recover from injuries quickly in the past.
The argument for either player depends on personal preference. Digne is considered the better defensive option, while Moreno excels in one-on-one situations and compliments Emery’s attacking style. However, Moreno’s confidence was visibly affected by recurring hamstring injuries last season, impacting his crossing accuracy and risk-taking attitude.
Emery admires Moreno’s progressive carries and considers it a standout trait. The left-back was Emery’s first signing at Villa and has a strong bond with his compatriot. Digne, on the other hand, is more of a traditional left-back who excels in crossing. He had to adjust his game at Villa, working on precision crosses with greater variation.
In terms of statistics, Digne generally has the edge over Moreno. He creates more shot-creating actions per game in the Premier League and is more purposeful in attacking areas. However, Villa will have to decide which player to cash in on as they look to strengthen their squad. This decision will be another challenge for the club’s hierarchy to navigate.
Overall, the left-back position is a key area for Villa’s improvement as they aim to compete at the highest level. The decision on whether to keep Digne or Moreno will have financial implications and impact the squad’s overall strength.