As the 2023-24 Premier League season comes to a close, fans from various clubs have shared their analysis and verdicts on their team’s campaign. Let’s take a closer look at what some of these fans had to say.
Arsenal: Oli Price-Bates from The Fresh Arsenal podcast rates Arsenal’s season as a 9/10. He notes the growth from last season, especially considering the added strain of Champions League football on the squad. However, he believes Arsenal must win a trophy to reach a perfect 10 and improve their performance in cup competitions. Oli also praises Gabriel as an unsung hero, highlighting his contribution to the team’s defensive record. As for potential signings, Oli mentions Alexander Isak as the dream signing, given his impressive performances in the league this year.
Aston Villa: David Michael from My Old Man Said rates Villa’s season as a perfect 10/10. He considers Villa’s return to the Champions League after 42 years out of Europe’s top competition a superb achievement. When it comes to unsung heroes, David highlights Youri Tielemans, who initially faced skepticism but became a vital player for the team. In terms of potential signings, David emphasizes the need to strengthen the defense and suggests calling Crystal Palace for potential forward players.
Bournemouth: Sam Davis from Back of the Net rates Bournemouth’s season as an 8/10. He commends the team’s performance once they found their rhythm but acknowledges that it took some time to get going. Sam also expresses his satisfaction with manager Andoni Iraola, who has brought back elements of Eddie Howe’s style and philosophy. When discussing potential signings, Sam mentions the return of Aaron Ramsdale as a desired option for goalkeeper and highlights Dominic Solanke as a player they would like to keep.
Brentford: Ian Westbrook from the Beesotted podcast rates Brentford’s season as a 7/10. He acknowledges the challenges the team faced due to injuries and departures but highlights their impressive achievement of comfortably staying up and never being in the bottom three. Ian considers Mads Roerslev an unsung hero, as he stepped up when other full-backs were unavailable and became a reliable player. In terms of potential signings, Ian suggests Ross Barkley as an ideal addition to bring more experience to the midfield.
Brighton: Scott McCarthy from We Are Brighton rates Brighton’s season as an 8/10. He acknowledges that domestic performances were likely to drop off due to the additional workload of European football. Scott praises Jan Paul van Hecke as an unsung hero, highlighting his performance as the best center-back at Brighton. As for potential signings, Scott jokingly mentions Wilfried Zaha for the drama it would cause among Brighton and Crystal Palace supporters but suggests Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall as a more realistic option.
Burnley: Natalie Bromley from the No Nay Never podcast rates Burnley’s season as a 2/10, reflecting their position in the league. She notes that the season has not been good enough on many levels. Natalie considers Sander Berge the unsung hero of the team and praises the medical team for their work with Lyle Foster on his mental health issue. As for potential signings, Natalie humorously suggests Sammie Szmodics from Blackburn Rovers to address their need for strikers.
Chelsea: Will Faulks from Chelsea News rates Chelsea’s season as a 6/10. He acknowledges some dreadful moments and major long-term questions but highlights their improvement by the end of the campaign. Will considers Trevoh Chalobah an unsung hero, noting his return as a turning point for the team. He also emphasizes the importance of securing a new contract for Conor Gallagher, considering him a homegrown talent who makes everyone around him better.
Crystal Palace: Alex Pewter from the Five Year Plan podcast rates Crystal Palace’s season as a clear 8/10. He praises the team’s performances and an unlikely 10th-placed finish. Alex considers Tyrick Mitchell an unsung hero, highlighting his development and excellent one-on-one tackling. Instead of focusing on new player signings, Alex emphasizes the importance of retaining sporting director Dougie Freedman, who plays a vital role in the club’s set-up.
Everton: Mike Richards from Unholy Trinity rates Everton’s season as an 8/10. He commends the fight and heart shown by the players and manager despite difficult circumstances. Mike highlights Jarrad Branthwaite and Vitaliy Mykolenko as unsung heroes, noting their contributions to the team. In terms of potential signings, Mike suggests securing a new contract for Dominic Calvert-Lewin and mentions the need for a proper defensive midfielder.
Fulham: Sammy James from Fulhamish rates Fulham’s season as a 7/10. He considers it a good campaign overall, with notable wins over top teams. Sammy highlights Antonee Robinson as an unsung hero, noting his impressive performances as a left-back. In terms of potential signings, Sammy mentions Gustavo Hamer from Sheffield United as a player who has shone in a poor team.
Liverpool: Jordan Chamberlain from Empire of the Kop rates Liverpool’s season as a 7/10. He acknowledges that the season did not end as they had hoped but still considers finishing in third place and reaching the Carabao Cup final a respectable achievement. Jordan mentions Wataru Endo as an unsung hero, noting his warrior-like performances. When discussing potential signings, he emphasizes the need for a proper defensive midfielder and suggests Manuel Ugarte from Paris St-Germain as a possible option.
Luton Town: Ollie Kay from We Are Luton Town rates Luton Town’s season as a 6/10. He acknowledges the challenges they faced and their near-miss in avoiding relegation. Ollie considers Carlton Morris an unsung hero for stepping up as captain and playing consistently throughout the season. In terms of potential signings, Ollie highlights the need for a good right wing-back and mentions the possibility of signing Cody Drameh and Sammie Szmodics.
Manchester City: Nigel Rothband from The Man City Show podcast rates Manchester City’s season as a 9.5/10, depending on the result in the FA Cup final. He acknowledges the team’s fourth consecutive Premier League title and the potential for a back-to-back Double. Nigel considers Rodri an unsung hero, expressing surprise that he was not nominated for player of the year. As for potential signings, he mentions the importance of retaining Stefan Ortega and suggests Mohammed Kudus from West Ham United as a player who could make an impact.
Manchester United: Alex Turk from Stretford Paddock rates Manchester United’s season as a 3/10. He highlights their worst Premier League and Champions League campaigns in recent history and the potential absence of European football next season. Alex considers Jonny Evans an unsung hero for stepping up in the absence of other center-backs. As for potential signings, he mentions Amadou Onana from Everton as a player who could strengthen the midfield.
Newcastle: Matty Renton from The Magpie Channel TV rates Newcastle’s season as a 7/10. He acknowledges their remarkable achievement of finishing in seventh place and potentially qualifying for Europe. Matty considers Wataru Endo an unsung hero and praises his efforts throughout the season. In terms of potential signings, he mentions Michael Olise from Crystal Palace as an exciting addition to the team.
Nottingham Forest: Pat Riddell from The Famous Club rates Nottingham Forest’s season as a 4/10. He acknowledges the promise and frustration experienced throughout the season. Pat considers Neco Williams an unsung hero, noting his consistent performances. In terms of potential signings, he emphasizes the need for a striker who can finish chances.
Sheffield United: Ben Meakin from Blades Pod rates Sheffield United’s season as a 0/10. He acknowledges the team’s poor performance, with only three wins all season. Ben considers the fans as the unsung heroes for their continued support despite disappointing results. As for potential signings, he mentions the importance of keeping John Egan in the squad.
Tottenham: Anna Howells from Spurs XY rates Tottenham’s season as a 7/10. She acknowledges the team’s impressive finish in fifth place, higher than expected. Anna considers Guglielmo Vicario an unsung hero for his solid performances as a goalkeeper. As for potential signings, she suggests bringing in a proven goalscorer to improve their conversion rate.
West Ham: James Jones from We Are West Ham rates West Ham’s season as a 6.5/10. He acknowledges the team’s strong start and memorable run in the Europa League but highlights their form decline in 2024. James considers Emerson Palmieri an unsung hero for his consistent performance at left-back. In terms of potential signings, he emphasizes the need for a striker who can score goals.
Wolves: Matt Cooper from Talking Wolves rates Wolves’ season as a 7/10. He acknowledges the low expectations at the start but commends the team for their overall performance. Matt considers Nelson Semedo an unsung hero for his contributions to the team’s playstyle. As for potential signings, he suggests holding onto key players like Joao Gomes, Rayan Ait-Nouri, and Pedro Neto.