Premier League Chief Offers Clarification on ‘Small Clubs’ Comment
Premier League chief executive Richard Masters has clarified his remarks after facing criticism for suggesting that Everton and Nottingham Forest were “small clubs.” Masters’ comments came during a committee hearing where both clubs were charged for alleged breaches of Premier League financial rules. The committee member Damian Green had questioned whether big clubs were treated differently in such matters.
In response to Green’s question, Masters stated, “The standard directions on the Premier League’s profit and sustainability rules are for everybody, they’re not just for the small clubs.” This statement drew criticism from Forest owner Evangelos Marinakis, who felt that it undermined the reputation of both clubs. Committee chair Dame Caroline Dinenage also asked Masters to provide further clarification, as she believed his remarks raised broader questions.
In a written response, Masters explained that his intention was to emphasize that the Premier League’s rules apply equally to all clubs. He stated, “Furthermore, I am happy to confirm that, while clubs can be delineated by many different measures, no such criteria or classification is used by the Premier League.” Masters acknowledged the value and respect Everton and Nottingham Forest hold as members of the Premier League. He highlighted their successful histories, passionate fanbases, and significant contributions to their cities and local communities.
Masters clarified that his use of the phrase “small clubs” was in response to the framing of the question by the committee member. He did not intend to suggest any unfair treatment based on the size of the club, as suggested in the committee’s media statement. On the contrary, he emphasized that the Premier League board consistently applies the rules irrespective of the club in question.
Regarding Everton’s recent case, where they were deducted 10 points for a separate breach of the rules, Masters reiterated that the commission responsible for hearing the case is independent of the Premier League. He emphasized that panel members are appointed by an independent chair, and the League has no involvement in the appointment process. Each member of the independent commission is a senior and experienced lawyer or financial expert, including individuals with a background in the judiciary.
It is worth noting that Manchester City was charged with over 100 breaches of financial rules in February 2023 but is yet to face a hearing. This highlights the ongoing commitment of the Premier League to investigate and address any potential violations, regardless of the club involved.
In conclusion, Richard Masters has offered clarification on his comments regarding “small clubs” in relation to the Premier League’s financial rules. His intention was to emphasize that all clubs are subject to the same rules and that the league treats them equally. He recognized the value and contributions of Everton and Nottingham Forest as respected members of the Premier League. Furthermore, Masters reiterated the independence of the commission responsible for hearing cases and emphasized the qualifications and expertise of its members. The ongoing commitment of the Premier League to investigate and address potential breaches of financial rules remains evident.