Introduction:
The 2024 NFL Draft has concluded, and now all 257 picks are beginning the process of settling in with their new teams. We reached out to The Athletic’s NFL beat writers to get their insights on their team’s favorite pick from the draft. While the term “favorite” doesn’t always mean “best,” these writers chose players who stood out for various reasons beyond on-field performance. Let’s take a closer look at what appealed to the writers about these players, with one pick highlighted for each team.
Arizona Cardinals: Zaven Harrison
The Cardinals’ general manager, Monti Ossenfort, made a great move in the draft by keeping the No. 4 pick and selecting Harrison. The dynamic playmaker is exactly what Arizona needed, and he has the potential to bring out the best in quarterback Kyler Murray. Harrison’s selection also brings star power to an organization that has struggled to make the playoffs in recent years. The fans are eagerly awaiting his debut and are excited to see what he can do.
Atlanta Falcons: Tre Bertrand
Bertrand’s selection in the fifth round was a dream come true for his mother, as he grew up just 20 miles north of Atlanta. He led Notre Dame in tackles for three consecutive seasons and has an impressive academic background as an Eagle Scout and finalist for the Campbell Trophy. His ties to the community and his dedication to both academics and athletics make him a favorite among Falcons fans.
Baltimore Ravens: Isaac
The Ravens have a reputation for selecting players who fit their defensive style, and Isaac is no exception. With a strong final season at Penn State, he plays like a Raven. Isaac’s upbringing with three non-verbal siblings has shaped him into a player with an exciting combination of energy and aggression. He should provide a much-needed boost to the Ravens’ pass rush.
Buffalo Bills: Coleman
The Bills’ top pick fills a desperate need on their depth chart, and he comes highly recommended by quarterback Josh Allen. Coleman’s exuberant personality has already made an impression, as he entertained reporters with jacket-buying strategies and even chose to wear the number 0, a rookie first for the franchise. His talent and charisma make him an exciting addition to the team.
Carolina Panthers: Legette
Legette caught the attention of scouts while playing against North Carolina, showcasing his linebacker-like build and receiver’s speed. He had an impressive season, catching nine passes for 178 yards and demonstrating his ability to high-point the ball. With his size and speed, Legette will be a valuable target for quarterback Bryce Young.
Chicago Bears: Taylor
The Bears’ selection of Taylor, an Australian punter, adds excitement and much-needed improvement to their punting game. The team struggled in that area last season, and Taylor’s talent and experience at Iowa made him a logical choice in the fourth round. The fans can expect to see a significant improvement in the team’s punting performance.
Cincinnati Bengals: Jenkins
Jenkins stood out as one of the most personable players in this year’s draft class. Known for his leadership qualities and natural charisma, he has already become a favorite among fans. With his freakish athleticism and energetic personality, Jenkins has the potential to become a voice of the locker room in the future.
Cleveland Browns: Zinter
Zinter’s impressive physical attributes make him a natural fit for the NFL. Standing at 6-6 with a massive build, he started for four years at Michigan, gaining valuable experience and battle-testing his skills. The Browns see him as a potential starting guard or center, adding toughness and versatility to their offensive line.
Dallas Cowboys: Beebe
The Cowboys addressed their need for offensive linemen by selecting Guyton in the first round and Beebe in the third. Beebe, ranked 38th on Dane Brugler’s draft board, is expected to compete for the starting center job. His value as a third-round pick is undeniable, and he has the potential to become a key player for the team.
Denver Broncos: Estime
The Broncos made a sound decision by selecting Estime in the fifth round. With his tough running style and red zone efficiency, he addresses the team’s need for a more effective running game. With Javonte Williams and Samaje Perine set to hit free agency after next season, Estime has a clear path to establishing himself as a multiyear contributor.
Detroit Lions: Arnold
Arnold’s story of perseverance and self-confidence stood out to the Lions’ beat writer. After being benched in 2022, Arnold used it as motivation to improve his game and never let it happen again. His determination and drive make him an ideal player for a team in need of defensive talent. The Lions hope that Arnold’s success story will inspire his teammates and contribute to their overall improvement.
Green Bay Packers: Bullard
The Packers made a calculated move by waiting until the second round to select Bullard, who was one of their favorite prospects in a weak safety class. Bullard’s versatility and ability to play multiple positions in the secondary make him an excellent fit for defensive coordinator Joe Barry’s scheme. The Packers believe Bullard has the potential to excel at both safety spots and nickel cornerback.
Houston Texans: Stover
Stover was one of the Texans’ favorite prospects in the draft, and they traded up in the fourth round to secure him. His elite size and versatility as a tight end make him a perfect fit for Bobby Slowik’s offense. Stover’s work ethic has been described as “elite,” and the Texans believe he has the potential to contribute immediately.
Indianapolis Colts: Latu
Latu’s journey back to the game of football after a severe neck injury is inspiring. After spending over two years away from the sport, Latu dominated at UCLA and became the first defensive player selected in this year’s draft. His addition to the Colts’ pass rush instantly improves their defense, and his perseverance will earn him respect in the locker room.
Jacksonville Jaguars: Thomas
Thomas, the Jaguars’ first-round pick, brings a potent deep threat to the team. With his impressive stats from his last season, Thomas has the potential to become a star alongside quarterback Trevor Lawrence. While he still has some areas to improve on, Thomas’ talent and potential make him an exciting addition to the team.
Kansas City Chiefs: Suamataia
The Chiefs’ selection of Suamataia was a smart move to address their long-term left tackle position. With his athleticism and youth, Suamataia has the potential to become one of the league’s best tackles during quarterback Patrick Mahomes’ prime years. The Chiefs were impressed by Suamataia’s energetic personality and believe he will be an excellent addition to their offensive line.
Las Vegas Raiders: Bowers
The Raiders’ selection of Bowers was driven by both his talent and versatility. While he is primarily a tight end, Bowers has experience playing in various positions, including slot receiver and H-back. Offensive coordinator Luke Getsy plans to maximize Bowers’ skill set by moving him around the field, similar to what he did with Cole Kmet during his time with the Bears.
Los Angeles Chargers: Hart
Hart’s physical attributes make him an outstanding prospect. As a former receiver, he has impressive size and athleticism that will benefit him as a cornerback. While his college production may not have been remarkable, his size, length, and speed give him the potential to become a starting outside corner or a regular contributor on special teams.
Los Angeles Rams: Karty
The Rams’ selection of Karty, a kicker, addresses their punting struggles from the previous season. The fans were vocal about their desire for a kicker, and the team responded by selecting Karty in the sixth round. His accuracy and reliability make him a valuable addition to the team.
Minnesota Vikings: Robinson
Robinson’s athleticism and pass-rushing abilities make him a valuable addition to the Vikings’ defense. He had an impressive college career at Penn State, recording 9.5 sacks and 17.5 tackles for loss over his last two seasons. Playing alongside talented players like Bradley Chubb, Jaelan Phillips, and Shaquil Barrett will only further enhance his performance.
New England Patriots: Baker
Baker’s ability to make plays on deep balls and create opportunities with the ball in his hands is a much-needed addition to the Patriots’ offense. The team ranked last in the league in plays of 20-plus yards last season, making Baker’s skills invaluable. If he can live up to his potential, he will greatly enhance the team’s offensive performance.
New Orleans Saints: Fuaga
The Saints made a smart move by selecting Fuaga at No. 14 to address their need for a starting offensive tackle. With the strong group of tackles available in the draft, they knew they could find a starting-caliber player at their spot. Fuaga’s selection is expected to make up for a previous draft pick that didn’t pan out, and he has the potential to become a key player on the offensive line.
New York Giants: Johnson
Johnson’s elite size, speed, and athleticism make him an intriguing prospect for the Giants. While his college production may have been underwhelming, late bloomers are common at the tight end position. The Giants see Johnson as a potential replacement for Darren Waller, who is considering retirement. With his traits and potential, Johnson could develop into a better professional player than a college athlete.
New York Jets: Stiggers
Stiggers’ journey to the NFL is inspiring, having left football after his father’s death and working odd jobs before joining a semi-pro league and eventually being drafted. His story resonated with defensive coordinator Jeff Ulbrich, who became emotional during their draft-day phone call. Stiggers’ work ethic and determination make him a favorite among Jets fans.
Philadelphia Eagles: Barton
Barton’s selection is more than just a feel-good story due to his father’s legacy as a former Eagles player. He is a versatile player who can make an impact in various ways. Barton’s ability to stop the run, get after the quarterback, excel in coverage, and contribute on special teams make him a valuable addition to the team.
Pittsburgh Steelers: Frazier
The Steelers’ interest in Frazier was well-known throughout the draft process. They fell in love with his skills at the Senior Bowl, and his proximity to Pittsburgh made him an obvious choice. Frazier’s selection fills a significant hole on the roster, and the team believes he has the potential to become an anchor on the defensive line.
San Francisco 49ers: Bullard
The 49ers’ selection of Bullard addresses their need for a tight end after injuries to key players. Bullard’s versatility and ability to play multiple positions in the secondary make him an ideal fit for the team’s scheme. The 49ers expect him to contribute immediately, especially while veteran tight end Talanoa Hufanga recovers from an ACL tear.
Seattle Seahawks: Haynes
The Seahawks needed to address their offensive line, and Haynes has the potential to become an immediate upgrade. With his mean streak on the field and positive attitude off the field, Haynes possesses the necessary qualities to excel as an interior lineman. The team sees him as a player who can make an immediate impact.
Tampa Bay Buccaneers: Barton
The Buccaneers’ selection of Barton is a significant move to improve their offensive line. With the middle of the line struggling due to injuries, Barton’s addition is expected to enhance the team’s run game and provide protection for quarterback Rachaad White. The team was fortunate to find such a valuable player late in the first round.
Tennessee Titans: Latham
The Titans’ selection of Latham addresses their need for a left tackle. While there were concerns about his ability to transition from right tackle in college to left tackle in the NFL, the team believes he has the potential to fill the role. Latham’s physicality and play style make him an exciting addition to the team.
Washington Commanders: Daniels
Daniels’ selection as the No. 1 pick brings hope and excitement to the Washington fan base. With his talent and potential, he has the ability to solve the team’s long-standing quarterback problem. While his success as a starting NFL quarterback is yet to be seen, Daniels’ arrival generates genuine excitement among fans.
Conclusion:
The 2024 NFL Draft brought a wave of new talent to teams across the league. From dynamic playmakers like Zaven Harrison to inspiring stories like Qwan’tez Stiggers, each team made selections that addressed their specific needs and brought excitement to their fan bases. These picks not only have the potential to make an impact on the field but also embody qualities that fans admire, such as leadership, work ethic, and perseverance. As these rookies settle into their new teams, fans eagerly await their debuts and hope for success in the upcoming season.