MLB Commissioner Rob Manfred has been vocal about his preference for a challenge system when it comes to implementing an automated strike zone in the major leagues. He believes that using a challenge system, where the automated strike zone is employed on a limited number of occasions during a game, would be more effective than using it on every pitch. Manfred stated that others are starting to share this view, but there are still many uncertainties surrounding the actual implementation of the automatic ball-strike system (ABS).
One of the key issues that needs to be addressed is the shape of the strike zone that the system would be programmed to recognize. Manfred has acknowledged that the strike zone as called by umpires may appear more round than expected. However, discussions on this matter have not yet taken place with the players, as the league has not settled on its stance regarding the shape of the strike zone.
Manfred shared that the league has gathered valuable insights from players on this topic. Initially, it was believed that players would be fully supportive of an automated system that could get every call right. However, discussions with players have revealed concerns about potential negative effects on the game if an ABS was used extensively.
Moreover, players who have had experience with ABS prefer the challenge system over a system that calls every pitch automatically. This preference has influenced the league’s thinking on the direction they might take with ABS implementation.
One group of players who could be significantly affected by ABS are catchers. Manfred highlighted the unintended consequences of ABS, particularly in relation to framing pitches. Catchers who excel at framing pitches are considered to possess an “art” of the game. If framing becomes less important due to ABS, the type of players occupying the catching position might change. It is possible that instead of focusing primarily on defense, catchers could become more offensive players. This shift could have significant implications for players’ careers.
Overall, while there is a growing consensus that the challenge system should be the form of ABS implemented in the major leagues, many details and concerns still need to be addressed. The league will need to carefully consider the shape of the strike zone, potential effects on the game, and the impact on specific positions such as catchers before making any final decisions.