Referees Urged to Trust Their Own Decisions and Reduce Reliance on VAR, Says Mark Clattenburg
Former Premier League official Mark Clattenburg has emphasized the need for referees to trust their own decisions and not rely on VAR. Clattenburg, who currently serves as Nottingham Forest’s referee analyst, believes that by making more on-field decisions and minimizing VAR interventions, the system will be more effective. Last season, Clattenburg noticed a lack of split-second decisions from referees due to their dependence on VAR. This led to inconsistencies and fan frustration. Clattenburg’s comments come after the Premier League and referees’ chief Howard Webb announced their plans to reduce VAR interventions and provide more support for referees’ judgments.
Improving VAR and Referee Standards
The Premier League has faced criticism regarding the standard of refereeing and the impact of technology on football. In response, the league has taken steps to improve VAR and referee standards. This season, the focus will be on the “referees’ call,” with VAR only intervening on subjective decisions if there is a clear and obvious error. Additionally, the Premier League Match Centre will provide “near-live” explanations of VAR decisions for fans. Clattenburg believes these measures are necessary to address the complaints and upset caused by VAR last season.
The Importance of Experienced Referees
Clattenburg acknowledges the challenge of maintaining experienced referees in the Premier League. He believes that while there are talented young referees, they are prone to making mistakes, similar to young footballers. To support young referees, Clattenburg suggests pairing them with experienced VARs. Currently, there are only two or three referees officiating the biggest matches each week, which places a significant burden on them. Clattenburg highlights the need for a more balanced distribution of experienced referees across all matches.
Clattenburg’s Relationship with Howard Webb
Clattenburg dismisses any issues with Howard Webb, despite Webb expressing disappointment with some of Clattenburg’s comments. Clattenburg believes he is entitled to speak and offer his opinion as an ex-referee. He acknowledges that Webb has acknowledged the shortcomings of the refereeing processes last season and is working towards more transparency in appointments. Clattenburg understands the challenges faced by the head of refereeing and the difficulties in making appointments that avoid controversy.
No Regrets and Dealing with Criticism
Clattenburg stands by his decision to take on the role of Nottingham Forest’s referee analyst, despite facing personal attacks on social media and television. He believes he provided value during his short tenure and that resigning relieved pressure from the football club. The FA did not charge Clattenburg for his comments, as he was fulfilling his job responsibilities with the Daily Mail. Clattenburg believes that referees should accept criticism and strive to improve their decision-making to avoid negative perceptions. He urges referees to focus on performing at the highest level and welcomes the opportunity to praise their good work.
In conclusion, Mark Clattenburg’s insights shed light on the importance of referees relying on their own decisions instead of relying too heavily on VAR. His remarks highlight the need for improved referee standards, including a more balanced distribution of experienced referees and increased transparency in appointments. Clattenburg’s experience and expertise provide valuable perspectives on the challenges faced by referees and the steps needed to enhance the effectiveness of VAR in the Premier League.