Manchester United manager Erik ten Hag faced speculation about his future in the build-up to the FA Cup final against Manchester City. Many believed it would be his last game in charge, with new United co-owner Sir Jim Ratcliffe rumored to be ready to make a change. However, Ten Hag silenced the critics with a tactical masterclass, leading his team to a 2-1 victory over the all-conquering City side.
The win was significant not only because it was City’s first loss since early December but also because it showcased a United team that had been missing for much of the season. The question now is whether this single victory will be enough to secure Ten Hag’s future at Old Trafford.
Ten Hag inherited a team that interim predecessor Ralf Rangnick described as needing “open heart surgery.” He has also had to contend with a long list of injuries throughout his tenure. Despite these challenges, Ten Hag believes that when his players are fit, they can play good football, as demonstrated in their win over City.
However, critics argue that Ten Hag’s lack of strategy and control has been evident throughout the season, particularly in their disappointing Champions League campaign. United failed to advance past the group stage, raising further doubts about Ten Hag’s ability to lead the team.
The FA Cup victory was not without its own share of drama. United lost a two-goal lead against Newport County in the fourth round, secured a dramatic win against Liverpool in extra time, and nearly squandered a 3-0 advantage against Coventry City in the semi-final. The triumph over City was comparatively routine but still showcased Ten Hag’s gameplan and organization.
Two teenagers, Alejandro Garnacho and Kobbie Mainoo, scored United’s goals in the final, adding to the club’s tradition of nurturing young talent. Mainoo, in particular, displayed maturity and control beyond his years, which could catch the attention of England manager Gareth Southgate.
The victory was also a personal triumph for Marcus Rashford, who had been excluded from England’s provisional squad for the Euro 2024 tournament. Rashford’s emotional celebration with the fans highlighted the significance of the win for him.
While the FA Cup triumph offers some redemption for Ten Hag, it does not erase the overall poor performance of the team this season. United suffered nine home losses and conceded a club-record 58 league goals, highlighting the lack of a clear plan or identity.
Ten Hag’s former colleague, Pep Guardiola, praised him as an extraordinary manager. However, this exceptional performance may not be enough to secure his future at United. Ratcliffe and the new football structure at the club will likely consider more than just one victory when making their decision.
For now, Ten Hag can revel in the glory of this FA Cup win, free from worries about his future. However, the long-term prospects for him and Manchester United remain uncertain. Only time will tell if this victory will be enough to save him.