Ralf Rangnick’s warning about the need for “open heart surgery” at Manchester United seems to be ringing true, as the club faces its worst-ever Premier League season and a massive rebuilding task. With four transfer windows gone and 22 senior players leaving, it is clear that there have been misguided transfers and a lack of long-term planning. However, there is hope that the new minority owners, Sir Jim Ratcliffe and Ineos, who now have complete sporting control after buying a stake in the club, can handle this task with care.
Looking at the current squad, it is suggested that all but three players are up for grabs if there is sufficient interest. However, the question remains, who would want them? Let’s take a closer look at each player and whether Ratcliffe and co should show leniency or swing the axe.
Goalkeepers:
– Andre Onana: Despite a dodgy start, Onana has proven to be reliable and one of the more consistent members of the squad. With a stable team in front of him, he could work wonders.
– Altay Bayindir: Reports suggest he is unhappy with his role at the club, so a sale may be the best option if there is sufficient interest.
Defenders:
– Aaron Wan-Bissaka: He has never made the right-back position his own and is no longer the starter there. With his contract up in 2025, it makes sense to cash in now.
– Diogo Dalot: He has been one of the most consistent performers this season and deserves to stay, especially considering there are more pressing concerns for the club.
– Raphael Varane: His injury record raises concerns, and Ineos can’t afford passengers if they want to perform the necessary surgery on the club.
– Harry Maguire: While he has shown character, his lack of pace and ball-playing ability are at odds with Man Utd’s desired style of play. Moving him on could be beneficial.
– Lisandro Martinez: With his left-footedness, Martinez could do wonders for the team if he stays fit and finds a long-term defensive partner.
– Jonny Evans: Given his age, it’s best to move him on, despite his steady performances this season.
– Victor Lindelof: Like Wan-Bissaka, Lindelof has been reliable but unremarkable. If a decent transfer fee can be obtained, he should be moved on.
– Willy Kambwala: He has been solid when called upon and should be given the opportunity to mature before being moved on.
Midfielders:
– Luke Shaw: Despite his ability, Shaw’s injury record is a concern, and it may be time to cash in and find a more available left-back.
– Tyrell Malacia: He showed promise in his first season before injury derailed his second. If he returns to full fitness, he could be an option for the future.
– Sofyan Amrabat: After an underwhelming season, his loan spell should not be made permanent.
– Casemiro: His disastrous performance against Crystal Palace highlighted that he may no longer be up to the required standard. Man Utd should sell if there are interested buyers.
– Christian Eriksen: As a free transfer, selling him would represent pure profit. His legs have looked gone, and Ineos should look for a player with similar traits.
– Kobbie Mainoo: He has shown promise and could be molded into a player who can dominate the midfield for years to come.
– Mason Mount: Despite injury troubles, Mount has qualities similar to Eriksen and should be given the benefit of the doubt until at least 2025.
– Scott McTominay: He has proven to be a brilliant plan B off the bench and should be kept for next season.
– Bruno Fernandes: Man Utd’s best player since his arrival, Fernandes should have a guaranteed spot in the team for the next few years.
– Antony: As one of the worst pound-for-pound signings in Premier League history, it’s time to cut losses on him.
– Anthony Martial: Out of contract in the summer and a drain on club resources, it’s best to let him go.
– Marcus Rashford: Despite his struggles, finding another player capable of scoring 30 goals a season will be difficult. Rashford should be given another chance unless a strong bid comes in.
– Alejandro Garnacho: He has made the right-wing his own and can improve with time.
– Rasmus Hojlund: Despite being starved of supply, his movement and unselfish play make him an obvious keep.
In terms of the manager, Erik ten Hag’s future is uncertain. Pundits have differing opinions, with some suggesting he should go if he doesn’t win the FA Cup, while others believe changes are needed but not necessarily a change in manager. Ultimately, the decision lies with the owners.
In conclusion, Manchester United is facing a massive rebuilding task, and the new minority owners have the opportunity to perform the necessary “open heart surgery” on the club. With careful decisions on player sales and acquisitions, as well as potentially evaluating the managerial position, there is hope for a brighter future for the Red Devils.