Controversial Penalty Decision Leaves talkSPORT Commentary Team Stunned
In a surprising turn of events, referee Andy Madley awarded Crystal Palace a penalty against Liverpool, leaving the talkSPORT commentary team in disbelief.
The Incident
Early in the second half at Selhurst Park, Liverpool defender Jarell Quansah made contact with Jean-Philippe Mateta inside the box, resulting in a penalty decision.
1
Credit: @footballontnt X
Initially, play was waved on and Liverpool believed they had escaped another penalty incident involving Will Hughes. However, 106 seconds after the challenge, referee Madley paused the game to review the incident on the VAR screen.
After careful consideration, Madley awarded a penalty to Crystal Palace, which was successfully converted by Mateta in the 57th minute.
Surprise and Disbelief
The decision to award the penalty felt delayed, considering the time between the tackle and the review. The talkSPORT commentary team, particularly Sam Matterface, expressed their astonishment at the referee’s decision-making process.
“What’s happening here?” Matterface exclaimed as Madley approached the VAR screen. “Is the referee going to check the push from all that time ago? He’s given a penalty! It was ages ago! If that’s the case, they had to stop the game.”
Former Chelsea defender Scott Minto also voiced his concerns about the decision, stating, “That’s a huge decision, that’s a big, big decision. Jurgen Klopp must be absolutely livid. The referee made that decision in a tenth of the time it took to overrule the previous penalty.”
VAR Controversy
Minto had previously criticized the role of VAR when Palace’s earlier penalty was rescinded after being replayed 31 times. He once again questioned the decision-making process for the Mateta incident, suggesting that the game should have been stopped during the review to avoid any potential chaos if a goal had been scored.
Despite the controversial penalty decision, Mohamed Salah managed to equalize for Liverpool in the 76th minute, scoring his 200th goal for the club. Palace’s chances were further diminished when Jordan Ayew received a second yellow card, reducing them to ten men. In stoppage time, Harvey Elliott secured a last-minute victory for the Reds with an impressive strike.
Conclusion
The swift penalty decision by referee Andy Madley left the talkSPORT commentary team stunned. The controversy surrounding the timing of the decision and the role of VAR continues to be a topic of discussion in the Premier League.