Why Having Two No.1 Goalkeepers Doesn’t Work, According to Brad Friedel
Having two number one goalkeepers at a club is a recipe for disaster, according to former Tottenham goalkeeper Brad Friedel. Friedel, who experienced a similar situation when Hugo Lloris joined Spurs, believes that it is only a matter of time before one of the two players becomes frustrated and wants to leave. With reports of David Raya’s potential move to Arsenal, Friedel’s comments are particularly relevant.
Friedel, who was 42 years old when he was replaced by Lloris, acknowledges that his situation was different. He was nearing the end of his career, while both Raya and Aaron Ramsdale are in their prime. Friedel argues that unless one goalkeeper is significantly younger and learning from the other, or the incumbent goalkeeper is nearing retirement, having two number ones is untenable.
The former goalkeeper points out the case of Matt Turner, who joined Arsenal and spent an entire season on the bench. Friedel believes that Turner should never have signed for Arsenal in the first place, as he is good enough to be a starting goalkeeper elsewhere. Sitting on the bench for an extended period can lead to frustration and discontent.
Friedel emphasizes the difficulty of maintaining team spirit, cohesiveness, and camaraderie when two goalkeepers are vying for the same spot. If Raya were to join Arsenal and perform well, only to be replaced by Ramsdale, he would naturally be upset. On the other hand, if Ramsdale were to lose his position to Raya after performing well, he would also be frustrated. This constant competition and uncertainty can strain relationships within the team.
The former goalkeeper also highlights the psychological impact on the players involved. When a goalkeeper has the ability to be a number one, being relegated to the bench for an extended period can lead to feelings of frustration and a desire to play. This often results in the player contacting their agent and seeking a move elsewhere, either permanently or on loan.
Friedel raises a crucial point for Arsenal manager Mikel Arteta. Even if Raya initially agrees to be a team player and accepts the role of the number two goalkeeper, prolonged frustration can lead to a change in attitude. This shift in mindset can create issues within the team and disrupt the overall harmony.
It is essential for Arteta and Arsenal to carefully consider the potential consequences of signing Raya. While Raya is undoubtedly a Premier League-quality goalkeeper, Friedel’s experience suggests that the situation may become problematic if he is not given consistent playing time. The club must communicate effectively with both Raya and Ramsdale to manage expectations and ensure that team dynamics are not adversely affected.
Ultimately, Friedel’s insights shed light on the challenges of having two number one goalkeepers at a club. While it may seem like a luxury to have two top-class options, the reality is that it can lead to discontent, frustration, and a breakdown in team spirit. Arsenal must carefully navigate this situation to maintain a harmonious and competitive squad.