The future of FA Cup replays has come into question recently, with replays set to be scrapped from the 2024-25 season onwards. This decision has faced backlash from various clubs and football governance groups, including Fair Game, who have launched a bid to stop the scrapping of replays.
Fair Game, a group that represents several professional clubs and campaigns for better football governance, has proposed an amendment to the upcoming Football Governance Bill. This amendment would require replays to only be scrapped after consultation with all eligible clubs and a majority vote. The aim is to prevent the decision from being made without considering the views of all parties involved.
The decision to scrap replays stems from the expansion of European competitions next season and the resulting pressure on the football calendar. However, more than 100 clubs have spoken out against the move, with League Two side Tranmere describing it as showing a “total lack of respect”. Peterborough chairman Darragh MacAnthony also warned that it could lead to fallout within English football.
Greater Manchester Mayor Andy Burnham and Niall Couper, the chief executive of Fair Game, have sent a joint letter to Culture Secretary Lucy Frazer and her shadow Thangam Debbonaire. In the letter, they express concerns about the impact of the decision on lower league clubs who are already struggling to survive. They also highlight the growing concern among supporters that the football authorities are prioritizing the interests of a few elite clubs over the well-being of the entire football pyramid.
Couper further criticizes the decision, calling it “short-sighted and misguided” and accusing elite clubs of protecting their own self-interests. He emphasizes the need for a strong and independent regulator in football to ensure the financial future of the game. Fair Game’s proposed amendment to the Football Governance Bill would not only cover FA Cup replays but also other competitions. If changes were to be made to revenue distribution, it would require approval from the independent regulator.
The Football Association has defended the decision, stating that “all parties accepted” the change. However, the English Football League (EFL) has called on the FA to “re-evaluate their approach”, claiming that there was no prior agreement or formal consultation before the announcement was made.
The Football Governance Bill, which includes provisions for an independent regulator, is currently going through the parliamentary process. It will have its second reading on Tuesday and will eventually become law. This bill is seen as a crucial step in ensuring transparency, consistency, and fairness in football governance.
The debate surrounding the scrapping of FA Cup replays highlights the ongoing tension between elite clubs and lower league clubs, as well as the need for a stronger regulatory framework in football. The proposed amendment by Fair Game seeks to address these concerns and ensure that decisions affecting the entire football pyramid are made in a fair and transparent manner.