England’s performance in the group stage of Euro 2024 has left fans and pundits questioning their ability to go deep in the tournament. Despite advancing as Group C winners, the Three Lions have been underwhelming in terms of energy and entertainment value.
One of the major concerns for England has been their lack of chances created. Statistically, their average xG (expected goals) of 2.26 for the three group games ranked them 19th out of 24 teams. Former England striker Alan Shearer highlights this issue, pointing out that the talented forward line has failed to fire thus far. He emphasizes the need for improvement in this area.
Former England captain Gary Lineker shares similar concerns about the tactical approach of the team. He questions why Phil Foden, one of the best number 10s in world football, is not played in his preferred position. Lineker believes there is a lack of balance in the team and doubts whether Gareth Southgate will adopt a more aggressive and high-pressing style of play.
Former England forward Ellen White identifies tempo as a crucial factor for improvement. She believes that when England moves the ball at speed, they are unstoppable. However, this has only happened sporadically in their matches, and she calls for more consistency.
Another issue raised is why players seem to perform worse for their national team compared to their clubs. England had created the second highest number of build-up attacks in the tournament but struggled with direct attacks. Former England striker Wayne Rooney suggests that this discrepancy could be due to players being accustomed to a high-tempo, attacking style of play at their clubs, while Southgate’s cautious approach requires a different mindset.
Rooney’s sentiment is echoed by Danny Murphy, who points out that many of England’s players are drilled to play high-energy football at their clubs but are asked to adapt to a different style with the national team. He believes this lack of cohesion and belief in their playing style is affecting their performance.
Despite the criticism, there are arguments that fans may be overreacting to England’s performances. In terms of chances conceded, England has the lowest xGa (expected goals against) measurement in the tournament. This defensive solidity, coupled with two clean sheets, suggests that their defensive structure is not a problem. However, there is a desire among fans and pundits to see a more attacking emphasis.
There are still reasons for hope within the team. Alan Shearer points out that England now avoids facing some of the stronger teams in the knockout stage. Gary Lineker highlights the moments of high energy and pressing that resembled Manchester City’s style of play, suggesting that this approach could be successful for England. Ellen White praises the team’s resilience and determination shown in the second half against Slovenia.
As for the upcoming last-16 game against Slovakia, there are suggestions for changes to the starting XI. Shearer believes that players like Anthony Gordon should be given a chance due to their impact in limited minutes. Former England defender Micah Richards suggests starting Gordon and Cole Palmer, resting Bukayo Saka, and making adjustments in midfield. White suggests bringing in Kobbie Mainoo for Conor Gallagher, while Murphy advocates for a front line consisting of Palmer, Foden, and Gordon.
In conclusion, England’s underwhelming performances in the group stage have sparked questions and criticism. The lack of chances created and the discrepancy in players’ performances for club and country have been key concerns. However, there are still positives to take from their defensive solidity and moments of high energy. With potential changes to the starting XI, there is hope for improvement and a more attacking emphasis moving forward in the tournament.