Judge Dismisses Defamation Lawsuit by Woman Claiming to be Jerry Jones’ Daughter
In a recent ruling, a Texas federal judge dismissed a defamation lawsuit filed by Alexandra Davis, who claims to be the daughter of Dallas Cowboys owner Jerry Jones. Davis alleged that Jones and two of his associates, Don Jack and Jim Wilkinson, orchestrated a campaign to portray her as an “extortionist” and a “shakedown artist.” However, Judge Robert W. Schroeder III determined that some of the statements made about Davis were either true or not defamatory, and ruled that she had failed to prove actual malice, a requirement under defamation law.
Background of the Lawsuit
The legal battle between Davis and Jones began in March 2022 when she filed a separate lawsuit seeking recognition as Jones’ daughter. She alleged that Jones had paid her $375,000 and set up two trusts to conceal their biological relationship. In her defamation claim filed in March 2023, Davis accused Jones and his representatives of making false statements and accusations about her character.
Judge Schroeder’s Ruling
In his 36-page order, Judge Schroeder dismissed part of Davis’ lawsuit with prejudice, meaning it cannot be refiled. However, he gave Davis and her lawyers the opportunity to amend their complaint and argue that the defendants had acted with actual malice in comments published in one of the ESPN articles. Davis’ lawyer, Andrew Bergman, stated that they would be amending their pleading and were pleased that the case was moving forward.
The Dispute Continues
The dismissal of the defamation lawsuit is just the latest development in a contentious dispute between Davis and Jones. The case has garnered significant media attention, with allegations of hidden paternity and financial motivations. Davis has maintained that her pursuit of recognition as Jones’ daughter is not driven by money, while Wilkinson claimed that Bergman had demanded a settlement involving star players Ezekiel Elliott or Dak Prescott. Bergman has denied these allegations.
Implications of the Ruling
Judge Schroeder’s ruling highlights the challenges faced by public figures when it comes to defamation claims. Davis was deemed a “limited public figure,” which means she had to prove that the defendants acted with actual malice, knowingly making false statements or acting with reckless disregard for the truth. The dismissal of part of Davis’ lawsuit suggests that she was unable to meet this burden of proof.
Moving Forward
With the opportunity to amend their complaint, Davis and her lawyers will have another chance to argue that the defendants acted with actual malice. It remains to be seen how the case will progress and whether Davis will be successful in her pursuit of recognition as Jerry Jones’ daughter.
Conclusion
The dismissal of Alexandra Davis’ defamation lawsuit against Jerry Jones and his associates is a significant development in their ongoing legal battle. While Judge Schroeder ruled that some of the statements made about Davis were not defamatory, he also provided her with an opportunity to amend her complaint. As the case continues, it will be interesting to see how the court evaluates the allegations and whether Davis will ultimately be recognized as Jones’ daughter.