Chelsea’s 2-2 draw with Aston Villa left them feeling aggrieved after Axel Disasi’s stoppage-time winner was disallowed. However, the use of VAR in this situation was questionable, as it did not appear to be a clear and obvious error. Former Premier League referee Mark Halsey believes that the referee, Craig Pawson, should have been more decisive during the game to minimize the need for VAR intervention.
Pawson had a good view of the incident and allowed play to continue, indicating that he did not believe it was a foul by Benoit Badiashile on Diego Carlos. Halsey suggests that if Pawson thought it was a foul, he should have blown the whistle immediately, eliminating any controversy. The problem with this incident is that it showcases technology re-refereeing a game, which goes against the purpose of VAR.
VAR official Chris Kavanagh recommended an on-field review, leading Pawson to change his initial decision. Halsey has observed Pawson’s refereeing style and feels that he often relies on VAR as a backup rather than making decisive calls himself. While the correct decision was ultimately reached, Halsey argues that the process of how it was achieved is not how VAR should be used in the Premier League.
The disallowed goal sparked protests from Chelsea players, who had to be restrained by their coaching staff. Badiashile and Madueke were particularly upset with the referee and linesmen. The frustration extended beyond the match, with Madueke expressing his belief that the goal should have stood and Pochettino criticizing VAR for changing the referee’s decision. Pochettino feels that such interventions damage the Premier League’s image and have negative consequences for himself, his team, their fans, and football as a whole.
This incident highlights the ongoing debate surrounding VAR and its impact on the game. While its intention is to ensure fair and accurate decisions, there are concerns about how it is implemented and the influence it has on the flow of matches. The case of Chelsea’s disallowed goal serves as a reminder that VAR should be used judiciously and only when there is a clear need for intervention. It is crucial for referees to make decisive calls in real time to minimize the reliance on technology and maintain the integrity of the game.