Anger and frustration have engulfed football fans as plans for a new competition after the scrapping of FA Cup replays have been labeled “ridiculous.” The Premier League is reportedly in discussions about a format that would involve 16 of their Under-21 teams and 16 National League sides. While the FA Cup will lose its replays, the National League could face fixture congestion through this proposed tournament.
Criticism has come from all corners, with Sheffield United boss Chris Wilder leading the charge against the axing of FA Cup replays. Fans have joined clubs and managers in denouncing the decision. However, the revelation of a potential 32-team event may shed light on why the National League has supported the removal of replays. According to The Athletic, this new competition would resemble the EFL Trophy and would feature four regional groups of eight teams, with National League teams playing the Under-21 sides at home.
The financial aspect seems to be a driving force behind the National League’s decision to back this proposal. Host clubs from the National League would retain all gate money along with half of the prize money. The remaining funds would be divided among the eight National League teams not participating in the tournament, as well as all National League North and National League South sides, totaling 56 clubs in total. The top 16 teams from the National League would take part, with the two clubs promoted to the EFL being replaced by the two relegated sides.
This revelation has sparked further outrage among fans. Matt Slater from The Athletic pointed out the irony of fixture congestion being deemed acceptable when it is subsidized by the Premier League. Many fans echoed his sentiment, expressing their disapproval of the proposed tournament. Some argued that including Under-21 sides in the EFL Trophy was unnecessary and that it would ruin both the FA Cup and the FA Trophy. Others questioned how the National League could consider adding more games to an already congested schedule this season.
However, there were a few supporters who expressed their enjoyment of unique competitions like the EFL Trophy. They highlighted the affordability of tickets, the opportunity to play against unfamiliar teams, and the unpredictability of the tournament due to teams not focused on promotion.
The proposed 32-team event has certainly sparked controversy and divided opinions among fans. While some see it as an opportunity for financial gain and a chance to participate in unusual competitions, many others view it as a detrimental decision that undermines traditional cup competitions and exacerbates fixture congestion. The debate continues as football stakeholders weigh the pros and cons of these plans.